Financial Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. We are not licensed financial advisors. Always consult a qualified financial professional before making any financial decisions.
New York Life Review
The financially strongest life insurer in the U.S. — built for permanence
Last reviewed: 2026-05-22 · By GBBR Editorial Team
Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission on qualifying purchases. Rankings are never for sale.
Our Top Pick · Silver Tier
New York Life
Custom pricing
The Bottom Line
New York Life is the safest life insurance company in America by every financial metric that matters — A++ from A.M. Best, AAA from Fitch, and a perfect 100 Comdex Score. Founded in 1845, it's a mutual company owned by policyholders, meaning eligible permanent policyholders receive annual dividends. For small business owners, New York Life offers standout key person insurance, buy-sell agreement funding, and executive benefit structuring that legacy competitors rarely match in depth. The trade-off is a completely advisor-led model — no online quoting, no digital purchase flow. If you want to click and buy life insurance in 10 minutes, look elsewhere. If you want the most financially secure insurer in the country to back your policy, New York Life is the answer.
What is New York Life?
New York Life was founded in 1845 and is the oldest mutual life insurance company in the United States. As a mutual company, it is owned by its policyholders rather than public shareholders — eligible permanent policyholders receive annual dividend payments. With $67+ billion in surplus and reserves, New York Life has paid dividends every year since 1854. The company expanded its group benefits division significantly in 2020 by acquiring Cigna's group life and disability business, becoming one of the largest group benefits carriers in the country.
What does New York Life offer?
New York Life offers term life (10, 15, 20-year), whole life with flexible Paid-Up Additions (PUA) riders, universal life, variable universal life, and individual disability income (MyIncome Protector). For small businesses: key person insurance, buy-sell agreement funding using permanent life policies, executive bonus plans (Section 162), and non-qualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plan funding. Group benefits include employer-sponsored group term life, AD&D, short- and long-term group disability, and supplemental health (accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity) through New York Life Group Benefit Solutions (NYL GBS). Pricing requires an advisor consultation — estimated 20-year term ($500k) for a healthy 35-year-old male runs approximately $35–$45/month.
20-Year Term ($500k, male 35)
Custom
/month
Whole Life
Custom
/month
Universal Life
Custom
/month
Key Person Insurance
Custom
/year
Is New York Life worth the price?
Advisor-only pricing — not the cheapest, but backed by the strongest financials in the category
New York Life's term rates run 10–20% higher than digital-first carriers like Haven Life or Ethos, but the mutual structure, dividend eligibility on whole life, and Comdex 100 financial strength represent genuine long-term value that discount carriers can't match
Fair valueHow we scored it
Overall score: 76/100
Comprehensive: term, whole life, universal, VUL, disability, key person, buy-sell, group benefits
No online quoting — all pricing requires an advisor consultation
Fully advisor-led model — no digital purchase flow for primary individual products
Financially guaranteed to pay — but administrative process draws mixed consumer reviews
Outstanding small business depth — key person, buy-sell, NQDC, Section 162 executive bonus plans
A++ AM Best, AAA Fitch, AA+ S&P, Comdex 100 — perfect scores across all agencies
Why New York Life is Silver Tier
New York Life earns Silver on the strength of its unmatched financial credibility (A++, AAA, Comdex 100), its specialized small business offerings (key person insurance, buy-sell funding, executive benefits), and its $75 CPL affiliate program — the highest lead commission in our insurance category. The platform falls short of Gold because the completely advisor-led model (no online quoting, no digital purchase) creates real friction for modern buyers, and consumer review scores (1.09/5 BBB, 2.0/5 Trustpilot) reflect genuine administrative frustrations with legacy insurance processes. It's the right choice for buyers who prioritize financial safety above everything else.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- ✓A++ AM Best, AAA Fitch, Comdex 100 — highest financial strength of any U.S. life insurer
- ✓Mutual company — eligible policyholders receive annual dividends
- ✓Paid dividends every year since 1854 without interruption
- ✓Deepest small business coverage: key person, buy-sell, executive benefits, NQDC
- ✓Highly flexible Paid-Up Additions (PUA) riders for cash value accumulation
- ✓Group Benefit Solutions division covers employer-sponsored life, disability, and supplemental health
Cons
- ✗No online quoting or digital purchase — advisor consultation required for all products
- ✗Consumer reviews poor: 1.09/5 BBB, 2.0/5 Trustpilot (administrative frustrations)
- ✗Generally not the cheapest term rates vs digital-first carriers
- ✗No no-exam policy options for primary individual coverage
- ✗Advisor-only model creates slower time-to-coverage than digital competitors
Ready to try New York Life?
Get New York Life →Frequently Asked Questions
Is New York Life worth it in 2026?
Advisor-only pricing — not the cheapest, but backed by the strongest financials in the category Overall verdict: Fair value.
What is New York Life best for?
New York Life is best for: Small business owners structuring key person insurance or buy-sell agreements, Business owners building cash value through whole life (infinite banking strategies), Risk-averse buyers who prioritize financial safety above all else.
Does New York Life have a free trial?
New York Life does not offer a permanently free plan. Contact the provider for current pricing.
Who should NOT use New York Life?
New York Life is not the right fit for: DIY buyers who want to get coverage in 10 minutes without speaking to an agent; Ultra-budget shoppers looking for the cheapest term rate.
What are the best New York Life alternatives?
Top alternatives to New York Life include hiscox, simply-business, aflac.
New York Life earns Silver on the strength of its unmatched financial credibility (A++, AAA, Comdex 100), its specialized small business offerings (key person insurance, buy-sell funding, executive benefits), and its $75 CPL affiliate program — the highest lead commission in our insurance category. The platform falls short of Gold because the completely advisor-led model (no online quoting, no digital purchase) creates real friction for modern buyers, and consumer review scores (1.09/5 BBB, 2.0/5 Trustpilot) reflect genuine administrative frustrations with legacy insurance processes. It's the right choice for buyers who prioritize financial safety above everything else.
Get New York Life →Community Reviews
Loading reviews...